Letter: Hyperbole in health care debate
Published: October 21, 2009
The health care debate rattling around this country has produced a wealth of propaganda, misinformation, fear-mongering and general craziness. From Sarah Palin’s “death panels” to Nancy Pelosi referring to private insurance companies as “villains,” both sides are guilty of extreme hyperbole.
As usual, Jon Stewart best put the issue in perspective when he said, “Conservatives scream so loud against Obama’s health care reform that they drown out the Democrats’ incoherence.”
In this important debate, the volume has been cranked up too loud by all involved. As a result, logic, reason and voices of moderation are being shouted down or silenced altogether.
Sadly, given the divisive political climate in this country, honest debate and cooperation between our two dysfunctional political parties in finding the best solution to this complex issue may never occur, especially when both sides are selling extra-strength snake oil to their sheep in an effort to inflame passions and “rally the base.”
One remedy for this aliment would be for all citizens to get their news and information from a wide array of sources. Although much of the mainstream news (especially cable TV news) has become little more than shills of the Democrats or Republicans, there are some quality, non-partisan sources (hard to fathom, I know) that help monitor the truthfulness, or lack-thereof, of the diseased cough of rhetoric emitting from all parties involved.
Far too often, opinion becomes fact, mostly through repeated voicing from talking heads. Both Democrats and Republicans claim a monopoly on the truth, but, as Einstein said, “Whoever undertakes to set himself up as a judge of truth and knowledge is shipwrecked by the laughter of the gods.”
Jason O’Neal Griggs
Dothan
Advertisement
Reader Reactions
I agree, a very good letter. As in most conflicts, one side does not have a monopoly on ridiculous actions, comments, and opinion.
On this particular issue, representatives from both sides have made good points. Unfortunately, they are drowned out by rantings of those concerned only about the actions that benefit them the most.
Hopefully, those making the decisions will come to an concensus that will be what’s best for the whole country.
Excellent letter! I completely agree with everything you said. You know it’s bad when you get more truth from The Daily Show with Jon Stewart (on comedy central)than the cable news channels (especially MSNBC and Fox News). By the way- The Colbert Report ain’t bad either.


News editor Christie Kulavich guides you to fun events happening in the Wiregrass.
Sports writer Drew Champlin writes about the latest sports news from Troy University.
Reporters Lance Griffin and Debbie Ingram write about latest news released on the country music development planned for Houston County.

Advertisement